We rarely feature bags that are questionably authentic, but we’re a bit stumped by our first celeb bag pick. (If you’ve laid eyes on a lot more vintage Hermès than most, please feel complimentary to weigh in.) Celebs can normally be counted upon to carry the real deal (except when they freely and openly admit that they don’t), but this bag-carrying celeb isn’t one of our usuals. It’s certainly not unusual to be fooled by a good fake in the secondhand marketplace, in fact, it’s not even absurd to love a good fake for being exactly what it is. Those are all authentic emotions. but is this bag authentic though?

Jemima Kirke
Jemima Kirke was identified heading into the AOL build series with a black, vintage Hermès Kelly bag. Something about the croc gives us pause though. The scales in the middle of the bag’s front panel look a little big? real or nah?

Jennifer Lopez
Here’s Jennifer Lopez, carrying one of her Christian Louboutin Paloma Bags around NYC. J-Lo’s love for this style goes way back. shop the Christian Louboutin Paloma Bag by means of Neiman Marcus ($2,290)

Jessica Simpson
There’s a lot going on here…drop-crotch pants! A Chloé bag we still can’t name! Děti! Presumably Jessica Simpson’s! Fendi sandals! LAXNÍ! shop Chloé Bags by means of Nordstrom

Kate Moss
Meanwhile, at JFK, Kate Moss made a much a lot more kicked back airport entrance with this stunning black Chanel Alligator classic Flap Bag. shop Chanel Bags by means of Vestiaire Collective

Nicole Murphy
Here’s Nicole Murphy, leaving a club in West Hollywood with a black Louis Vuitton Cluny Bag. Nicole Murphy has an exceptional bag collection; maybe it’s time we devoted a lot more blog space to it. shop the Louis Vuitton Cluny Bag by means of Louis Vuitton ($3,000)

Petra Ecclestone
It’s been a spell considering that we touched base with the Ecclestones (so long I was anxious they’d all become financially insolvent), but apparently, Petra got divorced earlier this year. She was recently seen carrying this Louis Vuitton petite Malle Bag to a dinner date at catch with her new boyfriend. shop the Louis Vuitton petite Malle Bag by means of Louis Vuitton ($5,500)

Priyanka Chopra
Here’s Priyanka Chopra, flaunting a purple The Row Ascot Bag while doing even a lot more press in nyc for the third season of Quantico. Sadly, her show just got the axe from ABC this week. shop The Row Ascot Bag by means of Barneys ($990)

Reese Witherspoon
Finally, we have Reese Witherspoon, heading into her office in LA with a Valentino Candystud Bag that bears her name in glittering studs, just as all bags should. shop the Valentino Candystud Bag by means of Net-a-Porter ($2,875)